Details of the Arrest
The Goodlettsville Police Department issued a 'Be on the Lookout' (BOLO) alert on December 16, suspecting Hay was heading to Oklahoma, possibly with a white male and towing a large camper. They shared her prior mugshot to aid in the search. Hay was arrested early on December 17 by the Osage County Sheriff's Office and booked into Osage County Jail on a fugitive from justice charge.[1]
Today's court appearance in Oklahoma on December 22 will determine her extradition to Tennessee. The vehicular homicide warrant also includes charges for leaving the scene of an accident causing over $1,500 in property damage and driving with an open container of alcohol. No details on the victim have been released publicly.[1]
This arrest follows Hay's ongoing second DUI case in Davidson County, highlighting a pattern of legal issues impacting her career.[1]
Rise on The Voice and Career Struggles
In 2016, Hay impressed judges with her powerful rendition of 'Redneck Woman' on The Voice Season 10, notably sharing a kiss with coach Christina Aguilera after choosing her team. Though Blake Shelton did not turn, Hay reached the Top 20, showcasing her country talent as an Oklahoma native.[1]
Post-show, Hay released music sporadically but faced setbacks. In 2022, she pleaded guilty to charges of inappropriate sexual contact with a 16-year-old boy, serving several months in jail. These incidents, combined with DUIs, have hindered her country music aspirations.[1]
Pattern of Legal Troubles
Hay's history includes a 2022 arrest for sexual misconduct with a minor—the son of a friend she was staying with. Reports detailed multiple incidents of kissing and inappropriate touching, leading to her guilty plea and incarceration.[1]
Additionally, she has an open second DUI case in Tennessee. The recent vehicular homicide charge exacerbates concerns over her driving record, with police noting the open container allegation in the crash.[1]
As developments unfold post-extradition, the music community watches how this will affect Hay's future.[1]


